DY responded to you explaining that point.
No, I didn’t.
Ubiquitin did not fardrei the Rema, but the issue is whether Chanukah gifts are rational, to apply the Rema to it.
I merely pointed out that the determining factor isn’t whether gifts in general are rational, but rather, whether Chanukah gifts in particular are. They very well might be, though, and then I in fact found that the Avnei Yoshfeh in fact holds that way. So, as per the Rema, which is completely relevant, it would be muttar.