So your response to
Does that make Paroh right? Obviously not. It merely means that in the big picture, nothing escapes Hashem’s will.
is
Now we can say according to this that whenever a Jewish boy dies its because look he would have sinned if he stayed alive. People who suffered along such as family members must also have sinned and deserve this punishment.
Are you actually reading the responses?
And to your first point (in that post), yes, that’s exactly my point. We don’t know the whole picture.