If one reads Emunos vedeios (Rav Saadia Gaon) he mentions 4 refutations concerning gilgulim. He acknowledges that some Jews belive in it but he felt it wasnt logical and it didn’t fit with pessukim. He also mentions the suffering of the young and refers back to an earlier treatise in his sefer to refute gilgulim. However,many great Rabannim hold of such an idea and both sides should not be dismissed,elu velu…
Menu