Rav Chisdai is the one who, after writing that it doesn’t make sense, writes that he heard that Al Pi Kabbalah it is true and if so ?? ???? ????.
That would be the reaction of anyone who is not versed in Kabbalah but found out a certain aspect of it, which is exactly why I said that quoting those from beforehand is irrelevant, since we already know it is not in Nigleh.
And by the way, my statement about how Rav Saadya Gaon’s refutation is not a Stira to Gilgul, would also answer the Ikkrim’s Kasha.
Where is the actual ??”? ?????