Reply To: Is it wrong to secretly not want moshiach to come

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Is it wrong to secretly not want moshiach to come Reply To: Is it wrong to secretly not want moshiach to come

#1132617
Avram in MD
Participant

newbee,

And every day people are wishing for moshiach to come to get rid of THEIR OWN problems so they can experience the bliss of what happens after death without the death process.

So what exactly is wrong with that?

Its human nature, but that does not mean its what Hashem sent us here for in the first place.

I would tend to disagree that it’s human nature in the long term. Humans by nature do not like to be indebted to anyone, so while a salvation might be welcome in the short term, some chafing might develop over the long term without character refinement.

And what do you think Hashem sent us here for? Does he need us? Does he need our mitzvos? Can we really do anything for Him? Not really. In reality, we are here solely because Hashem is giving us everything, so perhaps our purpose is to indeed become perfected receivers.

Ideally, I should have said I hope I don’t get the parking spot if thats what Hashem wants from me now and it will give me the best chance to grow.

That’s not what I would pray.

“Adam chose to pick a fight, so now we have to fight and deal with death. But that is not our ideal state!”

Again, this goes against the basic premise- that earning through fight and effort is better than receiving for free.

Suppose you ask your son to clean his room before dinner, and he suddenly starts smashing things, scattering papers and laundry everywhere, and rips his sheets off his bed. You say, “Why are you doing that?! That’s the opposite of what I asked you to do!”

He says, “So I can earn more reward by cleaning up a bigger mess!”

Does that thinking really make sense to you? Especially if his actions dramatically increase the chances that he won’t get his room clean by dinnertime? Would you really reward him more?