Home › Forums › In The News › What is the appropriate punishment for financial crimes? › Reply To: What is the appropriate punishment for financial crimes?
DY, North Dakota’s use tax was struck down (Quill Corp. v. North Dakota, 504 U.S. 298 (1992)) by SCOTUS. The Illinois Supreme Court struck down that state’s use tax 6-1 (PERFORMANCE MARKETING ASSOCIATION, INC.v. HAMER), Some states have tried to get around it by making it into a type of surtax on income taxes but until and unless Congress acts (the Senate passed a bill three years ago but the House has yet to pass it). Of course, one can get around NY’s completely by having the merchandise delivered to a friend or relative in NJ, which does not have such a tax.
As for criticizing other people’s failings, there is a mitzva to inform someone when he is violating the Halacha if he is generally observant. It is certainly a mitzva to make a general observation that something is prohibited.