Reply To: Soldier who killed the "neutralized" terrorist

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Soldier who killed the "neutralized" terrorist Reply To: Soldier who killed the "neutralized" terrorist

#1144434
simcha613
Participant

Joseph- I have to disagree with your analysis. Unless the Rambam tells us what the din would be in the case of an Eino Yehudi, how could you assume they are different? If the Rambam says that by a Yehudi it’s shfichus domim to use unnecessary lethal force but is silent on what the halacha would be for an Eino Yehudi, how could you assume the standard is different?