What kind of raya is that? We are discussing whether or not he is in fact ????? ????.
So what makes someone ????? ?????
Just note there are two different discussions going on which I don’t want to confuse.
The first is if the standard dinim of Rotzaiach, Rodef and other relevant laws apply to an Eino Yehudei, or are there other applicable laws (which no one has cited as of yet).
The second is if the terrorist in question was still a Rodef. For the purposes of our discussion, imagine it was in the USA, middle of Boro Park, and the attacker is a Bernie Sanders (Yehudei Tinok SheNishba) type member of Weather Underground.
Which are you responding to? I was responding to the second discussion.