Reply To: Thanksgiving: Church Holiday

Ronsr, I’ll take R’ Moshe’s opinion on that over yours any day.

As I wrote before: “R’ Moshe definitely did forbid celebrating Thanksgiving, because of his opinion that there is a general prohibition to add ANY set day to the calendar (even for a good reason) that wasn’t put there by the Tora or Chazal. R’ Moshe’s issur was even with the assumption that Thanksgiving was NOT a church holiday, per se`.”