Newbee: because you really don’t know enough surrounding the circumstances of the ban to have an informed opinion. It was a Rabbi that made it, nor some clueless layman.
Neville: As personal as this is for you, same applies to you.
Can you guys imagine a Kehilla of editeds (without being born to money, just marrying into it)?
That’s what the ban boiled down to, and that’s why MDD I wrote weak versus invalid, because it’s not always clear-cut. Even if the geirus is really Kosher, if they’re half-hearted about Yiddishkeit the family and kids will be effected.