Reply To: Source for Upsherins

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Source for Upsherins Reply To: Source for Upsherins

#1154978
ubiquitin
Participant

Joseph

Now your talking… I’m not sure, but I dont think any of those are a minhag.

Yet as usual you havent answered my questions (though perhaps answering a question with a question is in fact a minhag)

Here they are again

how long does it take for a Jewish practice to become a minhag?

Is eating cholent on shabbos (specifically, not just hot food) a minhag?

Is spinning a 4 sided top on Chanukah a minhag?

Feel free to answer the question to oomis as well

here http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/upsherins-are-a-minhag-shtus#post-612967