Reply To: Shaking hands with the opposite gender, in Israel

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Shaking hands with the opposite gender, in Israel Reply To: Shaking hands with the opposite gender, in Israel

#1155528

Joseph was citing a Sefer that quoted a Psak from R’ Belsky that seems to be the exact opposite of the one aIY says he got from R’ Belsky. That’s quite a fair point – no need for insults.

That’s very presumptuous of you. You are willing to make a statement that Joseph is quoting a sefer with a Psak that is opposite of a psak that was not even revealed to you. AiY was clear that he was not interested in sharing the words of the Rav, and yet you are going to defend Joseph for merely pointing out that it contradicts the written psak.

That is an inappropriate leap, and your desire to defend Joseph should not blind you to accuracy at someone else’s expense.