“Private schools are not supposed to receive direct aid. only indirect aid for things like Bus service and textbooks and some disabilith services”
You will notice that Joseph said private school COMMUNITY notprivate schools. The schools in fact on receive indirect aid.
On the other hsnd schools which are contracted by the district to provide mandated services, such as special Ed, even to students from families who are not part of the public school community, are paid for the services they provide. That is not government aid, that is fee for service. A very big difference.