SJSinNYC: Fair, but I was talking about Chazal. I wouldn’t act on my own without backup. Arguing without doing differently seems to me like that would be OK.
It’s like saying we see lice grow from eggs, but since Chazal paskened like they didn’t, we will “act” like Chazal Paskened, even though we don’t understand.
That is that mark of a Maymin. Not “not asking”, but asking and doing anyway.