Clearheaded,
You missed the point. *I* don’t have any questions about Iyov, Ben Sorer UMoreh or any of the other points I mentioned. To me they aren’t contradictions, they are arguments. I’m perfectly fine with one Tanna saying Iyov existed and the other saying that it’s just a parable. I don’t have a problem with one Tanna saying a BSUM never existed and the other saying that not only did he, but he even sat on his grave.
My question wasn’t about Iyov, BSUM or any of the other topics I mentioned — it was about Kasha’s statement that Chazal never argue about metzius when they very clearly do. I don’t have a problem with Chazal arguing about metzius. Kasha, for some unknown reason, seems to think this is an impossibility.
The Wolf