lol. That is really funny. When I was thinking this over earlier today, I was thinking that the only way I could see wanting a recycled engagement ring is if it had belonged to someone chashuve. Rebbetzin Kanievsky Zatsal was the example I thought of! And I had been thinking of writing that!
Tachlis, I’m still not sure. I could see either way. L’maaseh, I think I will have to have a chasson before I can have any idea how I would feel about a ring.