Reply To: Halacha: Process

#1185612

1) The Rif and the Rashba seem to disagree with that of Tosafos.

4) One could counter the main argument with the Meiri, the Teshuvos HaRosh, and a Mordechai. Examination shows that they are all address related, but slightly different issues. They therefore have little or no impact upon the main argument.

5) The argument based on Tosafos, therefore, is the strongest and should be accepted as dispositive.

This is of course with much oversimplifiction