Reply To: Would you post NEGATIVE Info about yeshiva/Sem/Camps??

If everything is Issur, you could never give an honest opinion of stuff.

I dont read novels, so I dont know what thread you are talking about, but obviously some are better than others and I am sure some are not good at all.

Ive read jewish books and some are better than others and some are unreadable. I have one book from a well known jewish publishing house that is unreadable.

I wanted to read the book and I had to stop after about 30 pages, Other people saw the book on my shelf and wanted to read it and they too gave up. What issur would it be to mention this book or the publishing house.

I think the publishing house should take proper critism and correct the errors in this book (Related to the proper way to write in english, Grammar, Spelling, Sentence , paragraph chapter development (It was paragraph and chapter development that made it unreadable)

Very few things in life are 100% good and 0% bad . its much more nuanced