lilmod, sorry for that barb, I didn’t actually mean that criticism (which wasn’t justified in any event) but rather was frustrated by your seeming implication when responding to others above in this thread that unless I switched my views on this issue to yours, that your opinion of me is dependent on my agreeing I’m wrong. That coupled a bit with my sense that your views on this topic are more strongly informed by the popular zeitgeist of advocates on this topic than of the halachic view on the subject which is abundantly clear in the shailos u’teshuvos seforim. And my (likely mistaken) impression that you were somewhat dismissive of S”A and teshuvos I presented in their applicability to the discussion. In any event I apologize for that zinger.
Menu