Reply To: Open Orthodoxy

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Open Orthodoxy Reply To: Open Orthodoxy

#1210393
gavra_at_work
Participant

As I demonstrated, they have mostly the same parameters.

I haven’t seen you demonstrate anything.

When I went into the Sugyah, I had fully expected to learn just like you, that if it is Assur for Kriyas Shema, than a woman has to cover it when she goes outside. I was unable to find anyone who said so. as I’m willing to follow based on the Halacha rather than my preconceived notion (unlike OO or extreme right groups), I had to admit that there is no tie-in, especially after Rav Moshe specifically says there is not one.

Where does Halacha Gimmel say anything about what a woman is or is not allowed to do? It seems to be discussing what a Man may or may not do, even in a place where everyone would agree that she may be unclothed or sing as such (a swimming pool?). Or are you saying that Halacha Gimmel only applies in the Shuk? (I think not!!)

If you can find me someone who ties the two together, I would be grateful.