Reply To: Charedi a Reaction to Haskalah

Home Forums Controversial Topics Charedi a Reaction to Haskalah Reply To: Charedi a Reaction to Haskalah

#1218614
ubiquitin
Participant

LU

“Apparently, they were Frum or he wouldn’t have bothered finding a limud zechus for them, and he wouldn’t have been able to find one either.”

I’m sorry I don’t follow. IF you are not familiar with the example, just ask I can elaborate.

do you have another definition of frum? IF a person doesnt follow halacha whether he drinks stam yaynam or intermarries then he isnt frum. OF course that doesnt mean we just write them off nor does it mean we should tell them they dont have to keep any other halacha. Especial yif they are

omer mutar” and otherwise not chashud.

The Remah I refer to is Teshuvas Hremah 124 where while finding a limud zechus for the community in question, refers to those who drink stam yaynam as “ovrei aveira” and is concerned by publicizing his teshuva othwer “ovrei averia” will follow this community

http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=1204&st=&pgnum=182

avi K

I dont think you are arguing with anything Ive said.

However, in regards to: ” you are over sixty years behind the times. The Chazon Ish said that universal life-long learning was a necessity for two generations”

How long would you say a generation is?

and how long ago did the Chazon Ish live?