Reply To: "Rabbi" Shmuly

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee "Rabbi" Shmuly Reply To: "Rabbi" Shmuly

#1225598
ubiquitin
Participant

Avi

search ” Jewish observer December 1972″

the very first link takes you to that issue on Agudah’s website.

If saying “his findings and decesuions are totoally invalid” or in the Hebrew provided in the link to Hapardes above signed by R’ Moshe “??? ????? ????????? ?????.” isnt disqualifying as a posek, I dont know what would be.

ROB

Joseph, isnt quite right on that point. IF you read the opposition to R’ Goren it stems primarily from critisicm regarding the way it was handled as put excelently by Beninugman.

Nobody claims he was “always” shomer Torah umitzvos ITs not like he was a kotzker chasid, however if he ever was, certainly in the beggining even if he later left, the heter still falls apart