Reply To: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin

Whether “rights” are “natural” (meaning, in the bottom line, given by G-d), or are based on law, is a highly philosophical question. If the government passes a law creating a right, it is then a right. Of course, what the government gives, the government can take away, and there is certainly no guarantee that a government administered “right” will prove to be wise and efficient (cf. the constitutional right to postal service).