NC
Welcome to the party
“Popa isn’t saying doctors aren’t good people….”
Nobody claimed he was.
” I think the point he’s making is that it’s a lot more intrusive in frum life than other professions. ”
Thats not just his point that is what the thread si about.
“That isnt jut his point that is what the You would have a home in which Dad goes to work every Shabbos; ”
Its not every Shabbos and its not every Doctor.
“that’s a bit scary for child-raising even if it is mutar. Kids don’t understand these things so easily.”
Kids are smart. The same way kids understand that when Tatty gets off his couch flashes hic cherry lights and saves the day its allowed, Dcotor’s kids understand too.
“But, if you are young and are thinking about med school, these are things to be considered. ”
Agree completely.
“They shouldn’t just be sworn off even if someone’s uncle’s cousin’s friend DID manage to make it work.”
Except it isnt just someones uncle’s cousins friend. That was PBA’s talking and he simply doesnt know what he is talking about. IT is many many frum Doctors.
And I mean those who take no call on shabbos at all.
Though I agree it is a concern and is worth discussing. But not in some hyperbolic manner devoid of any fact.