But the opening question can mean many different things, and until these are clarified, no one can answer anything.
I think you know good and well what he’s referring to.
As to the rest, it simply doesn’t address the hashkafa issue at hand, which is very firmly in the realm of daas Torah to decide.
Many of your own posts have crossed the line of what is questionable to be discussed in a public venue, and you (and others) need to own up to the fact that it’s not something to take lightly and decide on your own.