anon1m0us,
‘If Dovid or Saul wanted them to enforce the torah, like Yehoshaya, then they did, but that was not their job!”
Really?
Show us please just one single source that says that or anything a shred like it!
“Jewish Army follows the halacha, not because a King tell them to follow the halacha or because of the Sanhedrin. They follow it because each individual in that army follows the halacha. As stated, the Army follows the king, not Sanhedrin. If a soldier decides to follow Sanhedrin and not the king, he is killed for Mored B’Malchus.”
False
So Nov Ir Hakohanim deserved death for disobeying shaul?
If a soldier followed the urim V’tumim which was ignored by the Ruler
he is chayav?
“So to summarize, a Jewish Army Al Pi Halacha is an army that each individual upholds the halacha. Al Pi Halacha, this army can contain Men and Women. This Army can fight on Shabbos and when moshiach comes, will also ask Sanhedrin regarding halachic issues and since the king will be Moshiach, there will be no issues. Until then, the army follows the Prime Minister and asks all halachic questions to the chief rabbi.’
False
Judaism WAS a national public religion primarily
Even In the hashgafa of Rav Kook and the Religious Zionists founders, israel
was and is all supposed to be about the
whole Klal, Galut was of by default about the individual. That is why we had centralized control, while in the Galut, individual rabbis would make individual decisions about individuals.
‘Twas obvious before you were trying to force the suited Agenda.Now you openly came out and said it!
“Until then, the army follows the Prime Minister and asks all halachic questions to the chief rabbi.”
So you desire to abrogate political control from the representatives of the klal, the Sanhedrin, and transfer it to the Monarch. And then you’ll transfer the role of the monarch to the
“people’s representatives”, the knesset and the gov’t.
Very Well Done!!