Reply To: What would you say? – Hilchos Brochos

Maybe it’s because you specifically had in mind that the original bracha should not cover the cos shel bracha. You can ask the same question by the arba kosos by the Seder. Perhaps it’s the same answer there.

I’m still here, just haven’t had time to respond to your posts yet.

That would be a brocho sheina tzricha.

Arba Kosos is different. The Poskim talk about why each cup has its own bracha, and there are various answers. I don’t think it will help here.