Thefakemaven
Look Im not trying to convince you of anythingI realize that not all agree with me.
(Except for your strange acceptance and rejection of the distinction between mitzvah kiyumis and chiyuvis This part I dont understand why you are giving me a hard time. you acknowledge that there isnt am imyan to perfrom every mitzvah “only a foolish man…” Yet you also argue within it. note: I never said what category techeiles is in. )”
you say “think about this for some time, it is not too difficult”
I agree it isnt difficult. Your ” premise A) all Jews must do every mitzvah possible” Isnt absolute. It doesnt apply to all mitzvos “Only a foolish person…”) period.
“You have obviously not understood why I capitalized HALACHA.”
The very halachic process is built on mesora. Who do we foollw in machlokes Shach and Taz. MEchaber Tur etc etc. Am I free to choose. What If I find anew Rishon can I follow that. There isa mesora that guides the HALACHIC process. It isnt a free for all.
you want to argue that some things are more important than mesora. Fine. But to argue that there is no mesora in halacha is patently absurd.
“First off we don not paskn like aggadah,”
I agree, though why wont you answer the question, about Esrog.
“Actually you are contardicting yourself, since in such a case we are not uprooting a halacha, there is no halacha not wear techeilies”
Not super clear, as there may be a concern with techeiles is it isnt real. (not universally held I know)
And I said “uproot practice”
“