5ish- thank you for bringing up that point. There are countless stories about rabbeim of all stripes who did such miracles and nobody doubted any of it. The problem, again, is that CS will make the statement and then add the inference. She lists the miracles and then claims that it proves the rebbe’s equivalence to a Malachi, having conquered his y”h (not something a person is qualified to conclude) or oneness with Hashem. When the response was that we don’t accept the automatic jumped-to conclusion, she assumed we were denying that tzaddikim do this. Frankly, it just wasn’t even worth correcting her but since you brought it up…yes, rabbeim were capable of these types of miracles and there are endless stories about them. You are correct. It was neither unique to the lubavitcher rebbe’s, nor proof of the things CS (alone) attaches to it as fact.
Menu