Reply To: Carlebach niggunim

I heard quoted from a teshuva of Rav menashe Klein, his niggunim are assur, even his early ones. I have not seen it inside, and understand he’s generally pretty machmir, and certaintlt accept the above rav moshe. But to say we separate the person from the product is not simple, and not always true. To avoid having comments deleted again I’ll just say the problems with him are serious it seems we shouldn’t be so comfortable using his songs.