anonymous: And what you write “It’s very well known Rav Elyashiv spent his time on Shas and Poskim and was generally not the kind of posek who researched the….AFAR L”PUMAY!! That is right out kefirah and disrespect for a Gadol Hador….
For the first time since this topic was started I’m at loss for words. I have never said such things. How can someone who preaches so passionately about being careful with words fling theirs around so easily. How can someone who is trying to come across as protecting the kavod of Gedolim LeSham Shamayim be so flippant and condescending in their words against their brethren? “B”H we are not all Breslovers etc..”. Seriously, are they not Jews? Is lashon harah not an issur when it comes to them?
It would seem that your not interested in having a civil discussion about this important topic. You’d rather make disparaging remarks about Klal Yisroel. Self righteous anger is not a virtue…
I don’t see much gain with any correspondence with you since we are obviously here for different reasons. I want to have a discussion with others and hear different opinions so that I can learn new things, whereas you seem to relish in stirring up personal dissent. I’m not looking to argue, I want to discuss, something which you seem incapable of doing civilly.
As an aside. You also seem to be clueless with how one paskens. Although you may personally choose to follow the M”B in all his pesakim, I am not beholden to it. One may choose any one posek and stick with that one for all the hachrais. As has been my practice since I was a bachur I follow the Shulchan Aruch Harav in all cases. For you to make disparaging remarks against those that do not follow the M’B is something that the Chofetz Chaim himself would have definitely not condoned.
[BUT YOU LEAVE OUT THE MISHNA BERURA who quotes the Pri Migadim b’shem Maharal that one should be machmir l’chatchila.
Again I am at loss for words. This is what I wrote:I therefore do not have the audacity to say that for us nipitz is nothing more than a chumra.” In my dictionary machmir l’chatchila is synonymous with chumra.]
As for Krias Shema, nice quote from the Shulchan Aruch HaRav, but the M.B. is not machria and is not willing to be meikel like the Shulchan Aruch Harav, and it is a safek d’oraissah.
You should really learn Y’D siman 242 (and the last Shach over there) you will clearly see that this does not constitute a Safek Deoraisa.