Bshtei_Einayim:
Neville ChaimBerlin: Also, a video of Reb Chaim saying “if you had the real techeles you should wear it” as proof? Come on…
I think you missed my point with that. All I stated was that if R’ Chaim really learns (only) nignaz kepshuto, then it is impossible for ANYONE to be able to find it since Chazal definitely knew what they are talking about. Yet R’ Chaim did not tell the questioner that he must be mistaken as it was nignaz kepshuto. Doesn’t that sound like R’ Chaim understands that nignaz CAN be learn’t both ways?
As to your first comment, I beg to disagree, Iv’e spent over a year on this topic and have gone through virtually every pamphlet, as well as listened to numerous shiurim from both sides.