Reply To: The Killing of Nahal Haredi Soldiers and the Anti Draft Protests

“This young man was not killed in battle. He was killed patroling the territories where idf soldiers do not belong. If the settlers want to parade around the west bank, let them do their own policing.”

Wow.

There are people who agree with you regarding whether Jews should live in territories that were not under our control prior to 1967. Obviously much has been written about this issue. I have nothing to add that has not been said.

I am curious whether you believe whether people who “parade around” the Old City of Jerusalem, Ramat Eshkol, Chevron, Maale Adumim and the Gush should also do their own policing ? If not — how do you draw the distinction?