i knew that would happen if i didnt explain myself.
i brought the sdei chemed is to show how when a tzadik is alive hes student are supposed to believe that he is moshich (quote part of it – כתבו ג״כ תלמידי האר״י ז״ל שבימיו הי׳ האר״י ז״ל) – something which i tried saying before which you couldn’t agree with (i think on page 3)
now that that is answered with the sdei chemed we can go on where we see that meforshim hold that it can be from the dead – and not necessarily only doniel
(im just bringing sources where you see these concepts of
1. students believed throughout the generations that their rebbe is moshiach
2. if moshiach is from the dead it doeasnt necessarily mean only doniel – look in abarbanel thst i quoted Where he clearly raises the possibility that Moshiach may be among those resurrected)
now that you have the abarbanel read the first pirush in rashi again
btw did you have a chance to listen to the shiur
“you are at best a looney and at worst an apikorus” – why do u say these things if you never fully learnt ALL the sources about moshiach – i only quoted 2
obviously there are many opinions on the subject but to say that someone that has backing from one but not the other is a lunatic is a bit overboard
i dont know why we are even having this argument if you yourself said you never looked in ALL the sources about moshiach (not just the ones i quoted)
i hope this clarify’s