KY
“No. לשה”ר is much worse. It gets צרעת”
Interesting.
where does tzoras rank on the order of onshim?
“So which is worse גסות הרוח or neveila?
גסות הרוח.”
So If a person has a choice between being haughty or eating neveilah, youd tell him to eat the neveila?
“In his specific instance, he was beyond love struck. His talking to her was just a cover to having a mental connection to her. Ie. Fulfill his fantasy. In that case חזל said it’s אבוזריהו דארייות ויהרג ועל יעבור”
sooooooo, severity of onesh does not ALWAYS translate to severity of aveira.
“This one seems so easy you must have a trick up your sleeve.
חילול שבת-סקילה is much worse
ניבול המת I’m not sure there is any עונש down here for it.”
No trick,. though the defintion of “worse” is getting a bit muddled.
If a person is dying, and to save him we can either be menavel a mes or be mechale shabbos. Accordign to the Binyan Tziyon he should be mechalel Shabbos.
why would you do the worse averia, when we can do less severe one?
“To be clear, I’m obviously not saying it can NEVER be learnt from the onesh. Just that it can’t always be learnt from the onesh
Well well well
Once you go there we are not really arguing anymore.”
hold up, I said that from the get go!
Its a beferish gemra in multiple places.
I mentioned several times, that perhaps there was a distiction bein adom lemakom vs bein adom lacheveiro (Though Nidah/goyha doesnt fit well, maybe we can borrow your distiction