Reply To: Chidushim on Daf Yomi

Continuing on the above discussion of tefila betzibur. It says in SA O’CH 109,2 that over here the late comer would start with the baal tefila and say kedusha with him and not as usual with the tzibur. The RMA says there that it is not direct action. The Taz explains the view of the pointing to O’CH 125 that the tzibur should listen quietly to the baal tefila and over here he is saying kedushah with him. The Igros Moshe O’CH 3,9 argues pn the above Chasam Sofer likut shut 3 mentioning the RMA above. He can’t understand the Chasam Sofer such that he thinks the whole view of the Chasam Sofer is in error. The Shevet Halevi 4,11 says that he happens to recognize the words of the Chasam Sofer and what he is writing is correct. I don’t personally understand Reb Moshe ztzl question on the Chasam Sofer as Tosfas’ chidush is that the late comer recites kadusha together with the shliach tzibur and not with the tzibur which seems to follow exactly the view of the Chasam Sofer that the shliach tzibur creates the tefila betzibur.