Reply To: Socialism OTD

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Socialism OTD Reply To: Socialism OTD

#1885228
Ben Levi
Participant

Charliehall
I fail to see where I stated the Torah supports capitalism.

I did state that socialism is predicated on beliefs that anti fundamentals of Judaisim.

I fail to see how you disprove that.

Regarding Hilchos Aniyim.

First off the halochos of Hilchos Aniyim simply establish a obligation upon me to help out poor people it (probably) does not establish an ability for an individual poor person to demand from an individual support.

I do admit that this is subject to a dispute over whether it is mumon aniyim or not.

You are correct in respect that there is a moral obligation that derives from G-d but that does not ascribe itself to a a secular government,

Furthermore that obligation is predicated on my affording it.
Pray tell how does that translate into property taxes for school bills when I cannot afford tuition.

Secondly the Halochos of Charity establish many thing in direct contradiction to the secular ethics.

Again that is because the din of Hilchos Aniyim a requirement on me personally to help poor people no to give money to a third party which then does with it as they see fit.

If I have a job opening and a poor relative is capable of filling it I there is good Halachic grounds stating I am obligated to give to him.

And that obligation is for food and clothing how does that translate in Sesame Street on PBS?