Poskim can rule differently on the same exact question just based on who or why a person is asking.
For example, if a posik is familiar with a certain serious & responsible Avreich, then he is going to give him a different ruling than if the question is being asked by a person that is clearly trying to just “have ammo to win an argument with his wife”.
That’s 1 issue with assuming ANY psak is “One size fits all”.
Menu