Reply To: Chesed: Forcing the rich to pay for the poor

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Chesed: Forcing the rich to pay for the poor Reply To: Chesed: Forcing the rich to pay for the poor

#1970306

Yserbius > Does this mean that you are against any socialist ​policies?

ont sure who you are asking but every policy need to be evaluated against the damage it brings. Even libraries, for example, prevent authors from selling books, and thus reducing incentives for writing books. Obvious, for welfare. Welfare reform in the 90s showed that poor people benefited from being encouraged to work without increasing poverty.

We have example of R Huna throwing away leftovers from the market – so that he helps by decreasing market prices. Similarly, we allow competition between Torah teachers to make teaching affordable. Another lesson that comes across that Talmidei Chachamim were empirical – they institute a policy and then change it if society does not react the right way (first fathers were teaching Torah, but not everyone was capable, then they sent teenagers to Yerushalaim, but not everyone could send, etc)