AAQ – I never really know what it is you are looking for. My whole point was that you keep taking words a rabbi says and rearranging them and then assuming he meant that part as well. It wasn’t about agreeing or disagreeing. I didn’t have any hidden thoughts or comments that I refrained from including. My whole comment, this time and many others, is that you take things that individuals say and then use them to make other conclusions that you will also hold as if he said them.
You don’t owe me any detailed analysis. I don’t even want one. I was just wondering how you knew someone from his shul died. My guess was that you would not be willing to accept that there were no fatalities in his shul since that would go against your agenda so you declared a yid dead. But I asked anyway because maybe there really was a fatality, r”l, and I missed his mention of it. If not, that’s a pretty serious proclamation on your part. I hope you will take it back.