The biggest hero of the anti Ikkurim club would be the Rambam. But then they would need to study what he actually says, and that would ruin the atmosphere in the club.
Same thing here.
The biggest hero of the both dogma club would be the Ramban. But then they would need to study that he actually says, and that would ruin the atmosphere in the club.
When your club has the some level of workable theory, the same thing would instantly apply.
Yearn for Hashem, and do not mind being without any club or community. It is the only way out of this conundrum.