Reply To: Bachurim Smoking in Yeshivas

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Bachurim Smoking in Yeshivas Reply To: Bachurim Smoking in Yeshivas

#2042304

> and I wanted to know what he really held; not looking for a ptur.

good suspense. Waiting for the answer. Meanwhile, I do not understand the question. Do you ask same question when you are confronted with a sandwich with suspicious ingredients or see an ad for a movie? Does saying Shma twice daily fulfils obligation of limud Torah? Does saying “good morning” poters you from kibud Av vaEm the rest of the day?

I presume you usually do the safe thing and do not push towards the boundaries and try to do best in positive mitzvos. You may also look at your Rosh Yeshiva and try to be as polite, thoughtful, learned as him.

Why suddenly here you are ready to ruin your health and make yourself unattractive for a shidduch unless ordered so by your Rebbi?