Reply To: Denigrating Gedolim

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Denigrating Gedolim Reply To: Denigrating Gedolim

#2082608
Marxist
Participant

“First, The Oaths are quoted L’Halachah in numerous sources, including but not limited to: Piskei Riaz (Kesuvos 111), Responsa Rivash #110, Responsa Rashbash #2, Megilas Esther on Sefer HaMitzvos of Rambam Ramban (Maamar HaGeulah #1 regarding why all Jews outside of Bavel – the majority of Jews at the time – did not go to Eretz Yisroel at Coresh’s call), Rambam (Igeres Taimon – warning peple not to violate the Oaths or else face grave danger), Maharal (Netzach Yisroel 24) writes that even if the Goyim try to force us to take Eretz Yisroel for ourselves during Golus, we must allow ourselves to be killed rather than take violate the Oaths, as well as other places.”

As someone who reads old threads it seems that this list of sources was responded to by PAA six years ago:

Zionism, Why the Big Debate?

Unfortunately, the hebrew quotes have been reduced to question marks but can still be seen using the Wayback machine.

Or frumteen. Or daas torah blog. Most posts of his that are longer than a few lines were plagiarized from there.