You guys have some circular logic here: if someone is quoted and happen to confirm with your exact position, then he is a tzaddik gamur; if he disagrees with you on one item, then he is a rasha gamur. And you are confused if someone happened to say two things, one in each category. Why don’t you give some benefit of doubt to people with different views, try to see where they are coming from, and see how we can all live – and think – together.
Menu