Reply To: Talmeidei Chachamim with kids not like them

Since what I posted is edited, assuming you didn’t see it, you wont get a full read on my observations. That said, the question still stands the way it is now posted.

(BTW, I don’t see how what I wrote is more of an issue compared to many things posted here..it is a legitimate observation. Somehow discussing certain things tends to be worse in one direction than another which is silly…but I am not in charge so it is what it is.

UJM writes:

Based on…if a Ben Torah or Yeshivish person or Talmid Chochom has a son …a Ben Torah or Yeshivish or Talmid Chochom, then none of the criticism…

I was trying to be clear on this point. Yeshivish is mostly cultural…a father/son yeshivish is not what the gemorah is talking about…Now, yes, they may have what the gemorah says since they might be mimicking that as part of their culture…or maybe they dont have it…but try not to mix this up.

This mistake is highlighted in a mishna in Avos discussing this general idea (see Rashi there): Al Tistakel Bikonkon…