Reply To: Derech Emuna settlement

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Derech Emuna settlement Reply To: Derech Emuna settlement

#2117094
AviraDeArah
Participant

Goren was, as far as I know, the only person who rav moshe ever threw out of his house, during the mamzerim issue.

Goren also allowed essentially conservative conversions, much like eliezer melamed(melamed quotes goren…aveirah goreres aveirah), for the good of the “nation”. His qualifier was that they have to be like traditional israelis; because that’s religious zionism’s view of a Jew…an Israeli who should keep the whole torah, but if he doesn’t, he’s still jewish; you can join the “nation” by having an israeli passport and a conversion that obligates you to not eat pig, have a seder on passover and fast on yom kippur.

to secular zionists, the one defining trait of a jew is that he is israeli or supportive of it, and from the avos, even by patrilineal descent. For religious zionists, a Jew is that too, but he also needs to have some religion (but not very much) mixed in. For torah jews, all you need is torah to be a jew; and the torah has dinim about who a jew is, from the mother, etc…, or a convert who joins the torah community by embracing the entire torah, not just what traditional frei people do.

if anyone needs evidence of how zionist ideology affects psak halacha, look no further.