Reply To: The infamous club at YU – gone?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee The infamous club at YU – gone? Reply To: The infamous club at YU – gone?

#2120414
ubiquitin
Participant

UJM

“how do Orthodox Yidden teach in Conservative Jewish schools?”
you’d need to ask them

“Also, could you imagine RIETS being under the umbrella of the Mennonites?”

no, why?

” And the Roshei Yeshiva of RIETS saying we protested other Mennonite subsidiaries worshipping getshkes but we have no control over what they do?”

I don’t really understand, why would that be a problem?

“If not, why would anyone think being under the YU umbrella, with YU condoning and funding many aspects of outright kefira, any different?”

so its not different. nu nu

Damoshe wrote “Yeshiva University decided the time was right to ask for the legal right to block the club”

I don’t think this is correct. In fact the reverse is true, the current case was begun by the group suing YU.

In fact I think his entie post has it wrong “Let’s daven that their request is granted, and the club gets shut down permanently.” We can daven for that but I don’t think that is waht the lawsuit is about. YU is not fighting “the club.” that has been there that was “long opposed”

The Roshei Yeshiva can still be wrong for staying at RIETs when it umbrella organization supported such clubs, I never commented one way or the other on that. It is hard to imagine RIETS as a subsidiary of Menonite University, though if it were I wouldn’t have a problem if other subsidiaries of the university bowed to getchkes. If you do you do you don’t need to like it