CA: I’m not “knocking” anyone. I’m stating that we have CR Nev’iim adding to this proliferation of reasons being offered with purported certainty as to why the Ebeshter allowed or caused certain tragedies to happen. In some cases we have dueling or conflicting rationalizations for the same event. Everyone is free to assign whatever degree of significance or credibility to such statements depending on their source and context but the particular posting here on the consequences of space flight by yidden was a bit of a strech, even by CR standards.
Menu