n0mesorah,
“So to be clear, Rav Moshe’s opinion was against eruvin in Brooklyn. You don’t have to agree with it. Or even know why it fits with what he writes, but that was without a doubt his actual opinion.”
No that’s your ill informed opinion projected into Rav Moshe. Rav Moshe was not a rebbe, he was a baal halachah, who wrote his decisions based on the facts as told to him. If the facts are not correct, or have changed, there is no reason to follow his psak. Moreover, Rav Moshe never gave a psak di barrur regarding Brooklyn. Learn the inyan prior to pontificating.
Menu