Reply To: New Brooklyn Eruv: Time to Accept?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee New Brooklyn Eruv: Time to Accept? Reply To: New Brooklyn Eruv: Time to Accept?

#2198415

“The reason being because of the lies being presented as fact on this forum.”

The only ones doing that here are you and Richmond, to the degree that I’m surprised it’s even allowed.

“No one denied that Rav Moshe objected to a Brooklyn eruv and you cannot demonstrate that I said otherwise.”
And, then a mere few sentences later you say this:
“Actually, I offered several reasons why Rav Moshe would allow an eruv in Brooklyn”

“Rav Moshe is not a rebbe”
Why do you feel the need to keep saying this?

“Only when the issue is eruvin, do people have a problem that we peruse the teshuvos to see if they are applicable. ”

Actually no. We recently had a thread on here where posters were using a very similar argument that the poskim didn’t have the right facts, therefore they were wrong. In that case, the debate was about electricity on Shabbos, but it’s the same idea.

“A bunch a gibbrish. I never said any such thing.”

It doesn’t feel good to have someone publicly misrepresenting your opinions, does it? Maybe you should think about that next time you speculate about what went on in Reb Moshe’s mind.